The Nuances of Space in the Sukkah

hero image
14 Oct 2024
Sukkot

Many are familiar with the Vilna Gaon’s chiddush that the letters that spell the word Sukkah indicate the number of walls permitted. The samech is four-sided and closed to reference four walls, the chaf is three-sided to indicate three walls and the hei has two lines with a small line in the middle to permit a sukkah with two walls and a bit more.

However, there seems to be a discrepancy relating to the hei because there is a small gap between the middle line and the top, and yet we know there must be a connection between the walls.

It may be said that the hei is referencing another hei: Halachah le’Moshe mi’Sinai. Within this halachic framework, there are three laws that apply to a Sukkah which consider gaps as connected.

In dofen akumah, the bent wall, a protrusion from the house structure can be combined as part of the wall even though it now becomes a gap of non-kosher schach. Lavud allows empty spaces between walls to be connected so long as they are less than three tefachim from each other. Finally, gud asik allows an imaginary line to be drawn upwards as a connector even though there’s empty space.

This idea of connecting empty spaces would coincide with the Vilna Gaon’s holding that Sukkot is a commemoration of the Clouds of Glory, a manifestation of space that protected the Jews like a wall.

We know that we borrow halachos from Pesach to Sukkot, such as when in the month to celebrate and the shiurim of food to eat. In this way, we may borrow an idea from Pesach to Sukkot relating to the gap in the hei.

The letters in the words chametz and matzah, if rearranged, spell the same exact word, save the space in the hei, which prevents it from being a ches. Therefore, the difference between moving from a state of chametz, impurity, to a state of matzah, purity, is a little space. One need only take a small step and their life can be turned around.

This would complement the applicable halachos of filling gaps on Sukkot: if we open a space for God, He will complete the connection.